SameerKhan Tando Adam, Pakistan Member since June 2006
Some young people want to learn medicine and some other sciences, but there are obstacles such as mixing and having to travel aboard. What is the solution? How should we advise these young people? Answer:
Praise be to Allaah.
My advice to these people is that they should learn medicine, because in our country we have a great need for it. With regard to mixing, in our country - praise be to Allaah -a person may be able to avoid that as much as possible.
With regard to traveling to the kaafir countries, I do not think that it is permissible to do so unless certain conditions are met:
1 - The person should have sufficient knowledge to ward off doubts, because in the kaafir lands there are those who try to instill doubts in the Muslims so as to take them away from their religion.
2 - That the person should have sufficient religious commitment to resist desires, so one whose religious commitment is weak should not go there, lest his desires overwhelm him and lead him to his doom.
3 - There should be a need for his traveling, such as this specialty not being available in a Muslim country.
If these three conditions are met, then he may travel; if one of them is not met, then he should not travel, because taking care of his religious commitment is more important than taking care of anything else. (See more details on this issue in Majmoo' al-Fataawa by Shaykh Ibn ‘Uthaymeen, 3/28).
From Fataawa al- Shaykh Muhammad ibn Saalih al-‘Uthaymeen, Kitaab al-‘Ilm, p. 144
SameerKhan Tando Adam, Pakistan Member since June 2006
Asalam Alikum
Mery Bhai ye jo posting mainy ke hay mery apni nahin mainy khood search karke post ke hay or bagher kisy Kitab ke qutoe ke koi bhe bat post nahin karta khas kar ke Islam ke mutaliq ap nay shayad woh bat read ke hay abt kafir land par end par KItab Ka hawala nahin parha so ap ke liye doabara say Quote kar raha hon From Fataawa al- Shaykh Muhammad ibn Saalih al-‘Uthaymeen, Kitaab al-‘Ilm, p. 144.
Umeed hay mery guztaghi e jawab ko moaf kar ke ap thora sa Ilm ke mutaly ka bhe shoq farmaingy .
Quran aur Hadith k ilawa har kaalam aur kitaab mein galti ka imkaan hota hai.
Fatwa normal humanbeing Quran aur Hadith ke roshni mein dete hain magar wo koi Wahi nahi hote k jis mein galti ka koi imkaan na ho.
the point i m trying to make is that on internet nothing is really authentic and you cannot qoute anything with 100% surety , and not all mufti or Ulemaz aur good , Ilm Aml k bagair gumrahe ka sabab banta hai .
i m not critcizing respected Mufti sb i m just saying that in relegious matter try contacting some real and alive Mufti in the real world , so we all will have a better chance of guidance . before this i never heard anything like that from Molanaz and Muftiz . that they declaring peice of land as Kaafir land,
Makkah aur Madina mein b Kufaar Rhete the aur boht se aise lands jin ko Muslims ne fatah kia un mein b kufaar rahete the, but no body called the peice of land as a Kaafir land
CONAN BRISTOL, United Kingdom Member since February 2007
ASLAMO ALAKUM W RAHMA T ALLAH W BRAKATOH
PURI DUNEYA LAND OF ALLAH HA.
BHAI SAHIB AP KOI BE BAT KAR SAKTA HAN AS KY LIYA NA TO MAFI MANGA KI ZARURAT HA OR NA HI GHUSTAKHI KA LAFIZ KI ZARURAT HA.AP FRIENDLY BAT KAR SAKTA HAN MAN BE AP KI TARA COOL HON.
AK OR BAT MAN AP KO BATATA CHALON KA MAN IS WAKAT TAKREEBAN 8 ISLAMIC SITE KI MONEATRING KAR RAHA HON, OR YAHAN MAN IS LIYA IS TOPIC KO KABI NAHI CHARTA KA SAB NARAZ HO JATA HAN.
YA FORUM ISI LIYA HA KA HUM APIS MA MIL KA DISCUSS KAR SAKIN
MAN JAB KISI KA BAT KA JAWAB DATA HON TO US KO GHOR SA PARHKA OR US KI CHAN BEEN KAR KA HI JAWAB DATA HON
AP NA SHAHID MARI JAWAB BE THEEK SA NAHI PARHA
KHAR KOI BAT NAHI PHIR SA SHURU KARTA HAN
FATWA HAMASHA QURAN OR HADEES SA DEYA JATA HA APNI TARAF SA NAHI DEYA JATA, OR JO FATWA QURAN OR HADEES SA HAT KA HOTA HAN WO KABOOL NAHI KIYA JATA.
LAKIN AJKAL QURAN OR HADEES KA BAGHAR FATWA DANA KA RIWAJ AAM HO GEYA HOWA HA
IN KA FATWAON SA HAT KA MAN AP SA BAT KARON GA AB KEYONKA YA FATWA NA QURAN SA HA OR NA HADEES SA HA
AGAR AP SAHIB ILAM HAN TO AP ZAROOR SAMJHNA KI KOSHISH KARIN GA
(1)PAKISTAN 1947 KA BAD MARIZ WAJOOD MA AAYA THA , OR US KA LIYA PAKISTAN KO KOI NAI JAGA NAHI MILI THE INTIKAHAB KARNA KA LIYA , WO HINDUSTAN KA UNDER THA OR WAHAN PER HINDU GOVT THE.
AB KIYA PAKISTAN KO JO JAGA MILI THE US KO AP KIYA KAHIN GA KA WO KAFIR LAND THE, KIYA PAKISTAN BANNA KA BAD PAKISTAN KI SARZAMEEN KO GHUSAL DEYA GEYA THA,
(2) KHANA KAABA MA 300 SAL TAL " BUTT " RAHA. KHANA KAABA US WAKAT BE ALLAH KA GHR THA OR AB BE HA OR KEYAMAT TAK WO ALLAH KA GHAR HI RAHA GA.
(3) AB MAN AP KA 2 CLIPS DEKHAON GA UN KO GHOR SA SUNEYA GA OR CLIP DAKHNA SA PAHLA AK BAT MAN AP KO BTATA CHAON KA AGAR AP KO YA BANDA PASAND NA HO TO AP IS KA CHAHRA NAHI DAKHNA MAGAR WO KIYA KAH RAHA HA AP US KO SUNNA KA WO THEEK KAH RAHA HA YA GHALAT, TO AP KO US FATWA KI SAMAJH AA JAI GE JAHAN SA WO FATWA ISSU HOWA HA BINA QURAN OR HADEES SA.
Conditions of traveling to kaafir lands in order to study []
